YAS reiterates call for abolition of death penalty in MalawiBy staff reporterYouthandSociety(YAS)hasreiterateditscallthattheGovernment ofMalawishouldremovethedeathpenaltyfromthecountry’s laws.YASsaidthisonFridayinitscontributiontoapublicconsultationon theabolitionofthedeathpenaltyinMalawi.TheMinistryofJustice held the consultation meeting in Lilongwe.Initssubmission,YASnotesthatMalawihasinternationalhumanrightsobligationstorespect,protect,promoteandfulfillforeveryonewithinits jurisdiction, without discrimination.“Thesehumanrightsincludetherighttolife,therightnottobesubjectedtotortureorothercruel,inhumanordegradingtreatmentor punishment, and the right to a fair trial all of which are guaranteed under the Constitution and international law.“Malawihasexplicitlyacceptedobligationsinregardtotheserightsintheinternationalandregionalhumanrightstreatieswhichithasratified, includingtheInternationalCovenantonCivilandPoliticalRights(ICCPR),theFirstOptionalProtocoltotheInternationalCovenantonCiviland PoliticalRights,theConventionagainstTortureandOtherCruel,InhumanandDegradingTreatmentandPunishment,andtheStatuteofthe InternationalCriminalCourt—thelatterofwhichspecificallycommitssignatoriestoabolishingthedeathpenaltyfromtheirpenalcodes,and theAfricanCharteronHumanandPeoples’Rights(ACHPR),”thesubmission,presentedbyYASExecutiveDirectorCharlesKajoloweka,reads,in part.Accordingtothesubmission,thedeathpenaltywasintroducedduringcolonialNyasalandasadeterrenttouprisings,followingtheChilembwe Uprising which resulted in the execution of at least 36 Malawians. Thus, says YAS, the death penalty belongs to the dark past as it was a tool for suppressing the nationalist liberation movement. TheorganizationobservesthatwhenMalawirewroteitsConstitutionin1994,therighttolifewasguaranteed,withSection16oftheConstitution stating authoritatively that “Every person has the right to life and no person shall be arbitrarily deprived of his or her life”.“As the Ministry is aware, capital punishment was once a mandatory punishment for murder and treason. “In2007,theconstitutionalityofthemandatorydeathpenaltyforcapitaloffenceswasquestionedintheFrancisKafantayeniandothersvthe AttorneyGeneral(ConstitutionalCaseNo12of2005;[2007]MWHC).TheHighCourtruledthatitwasunconstitutionaltomakethedeath penalty mandatory for murder or treason convictions”. The ruling, YAS reminds, allowed judges to have discretion when deciding on sentences for murder convicts or those convicted of treason. “Indecidingonanappropriatesentenceinacase,judgesweretoconsiderwhetherornottheinmatehadasignificantpriorcriminalrecord, mentalillness,poverty,drugoralcoholintoxication,oldage,youth,trauma,ora"sincerebeliefinwitchcraft"atthetimeofthecrimeand/orat sentencing. This was the beginning of the re-sentencing project. YASfurtherremindsthat,InApril2020,MalawicourtsappearedforamomenttohaveabolishedthedeathpenaltyafterSupremeCourtjudge inthecaseCharlesKhoviwavTheRepublic(MSCAMiscellaneousCriminalAppealNo12of2017;[2021]MWSC,28April2021)heardthepetition ofaconvictedmurderer,andruledthatthedeathpenaltynegatestherighttolifewhichisotherwiseprovidedforundertheMalawi's constitution. “InthisjudgementtheSupremeCourtofAppealheldthattherighttolifewas“themotherofallrights”.Thecourtfurtherheldthat“withoutthe right to life, other rights do not exist” and, therefore, “the death penalty not only negates; it abolishes the right”. “Tomuchsurprise,fourmonthslater,theSupremeCourtissuedastatementsayingthejudgehadexpressedhispersonalopinionandthedeath penalty remained applicable”. YAS adds it is high time Malawi abolishes the death penalty, saying, for a very long time, the country has been abolitionist in theory. “YASbelievesthatthestakeholdersconsultationonthedeathpenaltyisanopportunityforMalawitosignificantlyimproveitsownhumanrights record, to mark itself out as a progressive force within the region and to align itself with the global trend towards abolishing the death penalty. “Abolitionofthedeathpenaltywoulddemonstrateagenuinecommitmenttoprotectingthepopulationfromanegregiousviolationof fundamental human rights”. YASalsozeroedinoninternationalandregionalscenes,whereabolitionofthedeathpenaltyisreportedlyregisteringgreatprogressand Malawi can learn from.The organization also gave five detailed reasons scandalizing the death penalty, further compelling the Government of Malawi to abolish it.Current statistics show that no known execution has taken place in Malawi since 1994. However, death sentences continue to be imposed. As of 2021, at least 25 people were on death row.
OTHER News
YAS,otherCSOsask Governmenttodrop criminal defamation casesBy staff reporterYouthandSociety(YAS)andotherthreeCivilSocietyOrganisations(CSOs) haveaskedtheTonseAllianceAdministrationtodropallcourtcasesrelated to freedom of expression.READ MORE
YAS, other CSOs decry worsening economic inequality as Malawi Celebrates International Human Rights DayWanangwa Mtawali-Nyasa TimesHumanrightsandgovernancewatchdogYouthandSociety(YAS)andits collaboratingcivilsocietyorganizations(CSOs)havedecriedeconomic inequalityinMalawiexacerbatedbythecurrenteconomichardships, describing it as “the worst” in recent years. READ MORE
YAS takes ATI Act to Local Councils: Calls for strict compliance by public officialsBy staff reporterInitsbidtocontributetowardsthesuccessfulimplementationoftheAccess toInformationAct(ATIA),YouthandSociety(YAS)hastakenthe disseminationoftheAccesstoInformationAct(ATIA)andATIAGuidelinesto district councils. READ MORE
YAS, other CSOs rue gaps in implementation of access to information law in MalawiBy staff reporterAconsortiumofYouthandSociety(YAS),OxfamandDevelopment CommunicationTrust(DCT)hasexpressedconcernover"somesignificantgaps" intheimplementationoftheAccesstoInformation(ATI)Actandoperating environment for the effective realization of the right to information. READ MORE
Charles Kajoloweka: YAS Executive Director
YAS calls for immediate resignation of minister Msukwa over Sattar's land corruption allegationsBy staff reporterHumanrightswatchdog,YouthandSociety(YAS),hasaskedLands,Housing andUrbanDevelopmentMinisterKezzieMsukwatoimmediatelyresign, followinghisallegedinvolvementinthecorruptacquisitionofsomelandby some Asian traders. READ MORE
News
YAS reiterates call for abolition of death penalty in MalawiBy staff reporter YouthandSociety(YAS)hasreiterateditscallthatthe GovernmentofMalawishouldremovethedeath penalty from the country’s laws.YASsaidthisonFridayinitscontributiontoapublic consultationontheabolitionofthedeathpenaltyin Malawi.TheMinistryofJusticeheldtheconsultation meeting in Lilongwe.Initssubmission,YASnotesthatMalawihasinternational humanrightsobligationstorespect,protect,promote andfulfillforeveryonewithinitsjurisdiction,without discrimination.“Thesehumanrightsincludetherighttolife,therightnot tobesubjectedtotortureorothercruel,inhumanor degradingtreatmentorpunishment,andtherighttoa fair trial all of which areguaranteedundertheConstitutionandinternational law.“Malawihasexplicitlyacceptedobligationsinregardto theserightsintheinternationalandregionalhuman rightstreatieswhichithasratified,includingthe InternationalCovenantonCivilandPoliticalRights (ICCPR),theFirstOptionalProtocoltotheInternational CovenantonCivilandPoliticalRights,theConvention againstTortureandOtherCruel,Inhumanand DegradingTreatmentandPunishment,andtheStatute oftheInternationalCriminalCourt—thelatterofwhich specificallycommitssignatoriestoabolishingthedeath penaltyfromtheirpenalcodes,andtheAfricanCharter onHumanandPeoples’Rights(ACHPR),”the submission,presentedbyYASExecutiveDirectorCharles Kajoloweka, reads, in part.Accordingtothesubmission,thedeathpenaltywas introducedduringcolonialNyasalandasadeterrentto uprisings,followingtheChilembweUprisingwhich resulted in the execution of at least 36 Malawians. Thus,saysYAS,thedeathpenaltybelongstothedark pastasitwasatoolforsuppressingthenationalist liberation movement. TheorganizationobservesthatwhenMalawirewroteits Constitutionin1994,therighttolifewasguaranteed, withSection16oftheConstitutionstatingauthoritatively that“Everypersonhastherighttolifeandnoperson shall be arbitrarily deprived of his or her life”.“AstheMinistryisaware,capitalpunishmentwasoncea mandatory punishment for murder and treason. “In2007,theconstitutionalityofthemandatorydeath penaltyforcapitaloffenceswasquestionedinthe FrancisKafantayeniandothersvtheAttorneyGeneral (ConstitutionalCaseNo12of2005;[2007]MWHC).The HighCourtruledthatitwasunconstitutionaltomakethe deathpenaltymandatoryformurderortreason convictions”. Theruling,YASreminds,allowedjudgestohave discretionwhendecidingonsentencesformurder convicts or those convicted of treason. “Indecidingonanappropriatesentenceinacase, judgesweretoconsiderwhetherornottheinmatehad asignificantpriorcriminalrecord,mentalillness,poverty, drugoralcoholintoxication,oldage,youth,trauma,or a"sincerebeliefinwitchcraft"atthetimeofthecrime and/oratsentencing.Thiswasthebeginningofthere-sentencing project. YASfurtherremindsthat,InApril2020,Malawicourts appearedforamomenttohaveabolishedthedeath penaltyafterSupremeCourtjudgeinthecaseCharles KhoviwavTheRepublic(MSCAMiscellaneousCriminal AppealNo12of2017;[2021]MWSC,28April2021) heardthepetitionofaconvictedmurderer,andruled thatthedeathpenaltynegatestherighttolifewhichis otherwise provided for under the Malawi's constitution. “InthisjudgementtheSupremeCourtofAppealheld thattherighttolifewas“themotherofallrights”.The courtfurtherheldthat“withouttherighttolife,other rightsdonotexist”and,therefore,“thedeathpenalty not only negates; it abolishes the right”. “Tomuchsurprise,fourmonthslater,theSupremeCourt issuedastatementsayingthejudgehadexpressedhis personalopinionandthedeathpenaltyremained applicable”. YASaddsitishightimeMalawiabolishesthedeath penalty,saying,foraverylongtime,thecountryhas been abolitionist in theory. “YASbelievesthatthestakeholdersconsultationonthe deathpenaltyisanopportunityforMalawito significantlyimproveitsownhumanrightsrecord,to markitselfoutasaprogressiveforcewithintheregion andtoalignitselfwiththeglobaltrendtowards abolishing the death penalty. “Abolitionofthedeathpenaltywoulddemonstratea genuinecommitmenttoprotectingthepopulationfrom an egregious violation of fundamental human rights”. YASalsozeroedinoninternationalandregionalscenes, whereabolitionofthedeathpenaltyisreportedly registering great progress and Malawi can learn from.Theorganizationalsogavefivedetailedreasons scandalizingthedeathpenalty,furthercompellingthe Government of Malawi to abolish it.Currentstatisticsshowthatnoknownexecutionhas takenplaceinMalawisince1994.However,death sentences continue to be imposed. As of 2021, at least 25 people were on death row.
YAS, other CSOs rue gaps in implementation of access to information law in MalawiBy staff reporterAconsortiumofYouthandSociety(YAS),Oxfamand DevelopmentCommunicationTrust(DCT)hasexpressed concernover"somesignificantgaps"inthe implementationoftheAccesstoInformation(ATI)Act andoperatingenvironmentfortheeffectiverealization of the right to information. READ MORE
YAS takes ATI Act to Local Councils: Calls for strict compliance by public officialsBy staff reporterInitsbidtocontributetowardsthesuccessful implementationoftheAccesstoInformationAct(ATIA), YouthandSociety(YAS)hastakenthedisseminationof theAccesstoInformationAct(ATIA)andATIA Guidelines to district councils. READ MORE
YAS, other CSOs decry worsening economic inequality as Malawi Celebrates International Human Rights Day. officialsWanangwa Mtawali-Nyasa TimesHumanrightsandgovernancewatchdogYouthand Society(YAS)anditscollaboratingcivilsociety organizations(CSOs)havedecriedeconomicinequality inMalawiexacerbatedbythecurrenteconomic hardships,describingitas“theworst”inrecentyears.READ MORE
YAS calls for immediate resignation of minister Msukwa over Sattar's land corruption allegationsBy staff reporter Humanrightswatchdog,YouthandSociety(YAS),has askedLands,HousingandUrbanDevelopmentMinister KezzieMsukwatoimmediatelyresign,followinghis allegedinvolvementinthecorruptacquisitionofsome land by some Asian traders. READ MORE
Charles Kajoloweka: YAS Executive Director
OTHER News
YAS, other CSOs ask Government to drop criminal defamation casesBy staff reporter YouthandSociety(YAS)andotherthreeCivilSociety Organisations(CSOs)haveaskedtheTonseAlliance Administrationtodropallcourtcasesrelatedto freedom of expression. READ MORE